In search of the best Sayville restaurants for a fun meal time?
In 1655, early settlers came to Long Island, they built their first home in Sayville 106 years later. Sitting in the Great South Bay of New York, Sayville offers life around the Atlantic Ocean. You may immerse yourself in fishing, boating, and swimming when you find yourself there.
Besides, the ferry terminal connects the Island, Mainland and the Atlantic Ocean. Coming to downtown Sayville, you will find boutiques, shops, and restaurants catering to locals and tourists. If you are a food lover, you may want to know that most Sayville restaurants are five miles apart.
You can choose to sit by the waters and enjoy your desserts or have them serve you a plate of seafood indoors. Whatever the case, Sayville is a place to enjoy healthy and nourishing meals.
Here are the best restaurants in Sayville and what makes them pleasant places to visit.
Best Sayville Restaurants
1. Café Joelle on the Main Street
Favorite among locals and visitors alike, Café Joelle is a warm storefront restaurant everyone should visit at least once in a lifetime. It has some touches of colorful wood floors, ceiling fans, and strings of small, overhanging lights.
It is co-owned by Steve Sands and Jules Buitron, who oversees the kitchen and ensure the guests receive friendly treatment.
Among the meals served in this Sayville restaurant are pasta dishes, burgers and salads. You can also order more considerable meals like a maple-dijon encrusted rack of lamb. Their staple foods are German dishes and weekend brunches are a hit here.
Café Joelle is open on Monday to Friday, from 12 – 10 pm and Saturday and Sunday, from 12 – 10:30 pm. This is one of the best Sayville restaurants to add to your bucket list.
Address: 25 Main Street, Sayville, NY 11782 USA. Phone: 631-589-4600
2. Butera’s of Sayville
Stepping into this South Shore restaurant, you will be warmly welcomed by both the staff and interior designs.
It is famous for its home-style Italian foods and copious breadbaskets. The setting is ideal for a family or group of friends who wishes to share laughter in a home away from home.
Expect to satisfy your appetite with spaghetti and chicken meatballs, grilled rustica pizza, or grilled scallop salad.
Another highlight of Butera’s is the full menu of fine wines to give your dish a romantic feel. Complementing the dish with a glass of wine will add to your culinary experience.
One more thing, you can walk into their gift shop to pick up something for your loved ones.
Butera’s of Sayville is open Monday to Thursday, from 11:30 am – 9:00 pm, Friday 11:30 am – 10:30 pm, Saturday from 1:00 – 10:30 pm and Sunday from 1:00 pm – 9:00 pm.
Address: 100 S. Main Street, Sayville, New York, 11782, USA. Phone: 631-563-0805
3. Five Points Café
Suppose you are a lover of burgers and need one of the unfussy Sayville restaurants to have one. In that case, you can head to this eponymous burger place.
Their terrific burgers are made with diverse sautéed onions, cheeses and secret sauce. This is why newcomers to this Main Street restaurant do not hesitate to make themselves comfortable.
The environment is vibrant, and both indoor and outdoor services are available. Be sure to enjoy your meal amid cool music playing in the background.
Even though your dinner date wants something different from the menu, Five Point Café will know how to twist the setting for you.
Whether you are vegan or non-vegan, you will always find something spectacular for you. For example, their delicious veggie burger, packed with sweet potato and spinach, is second-to-none.
Beer lovers are welcome too.
Point Five Café is open on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday from 4 – 7 pm, and Thursday 4 -9 pm.
Address: 1 Main St., Sayville, New York 11782, USA. Phone: 631-567–5655
4. Cricket’s
This is another choice spot in Sayville for families and friends to have some beautiful moments over a plate of food. It has a warm and homely atmosphere, complimenting a lively mood.
The item list includes sandwiches, burgers, steaks, appetizers, and crusty bread. If you are a cake lover, you should find yourself in Cricket Restaurant for some popovers.
You can grab a frosty draft from the bar on weekends while enjoying some popcorn. It is one of New York’s places where you can find casual lunch and dinner.
Cricket’s is closed for business for now but may open later.
Address: 98 Main St., Sayville, New York 11782, USA. Phone: 631-567–6345
5. The View
Amongst the top Sayville restaurants is The View, a classic place for seafood lovers. A wall of windows offers incredible outlooks of the Great South Bay and sitting in a good spot can be amazing.
The menu includes seasonal seafood and raw bar, served in modern small dishes. In addition, you can find Manhattan clam chowder, filet mignon, Peking duck tacos and other traditional foods to whet your appetite.
On weekends, you can come over for your sushi and on Sunday, you can step in for your brunch.
All foods are budget friendly at The View. In addition, if you have a little party you might want to hold, there are some cool spots at the restaurant. Live bands are constantly entertaining guests with traditional music.
To ensure something for the weekend, you can book your favorite meal ahead.
The View is closed on Monday. But open on Tuesday to Thursday, from 12 – 9 pm, Friday from 12 – 10 pm, Saturday 12 – 10:30 pm and Sunday from 11 am – 8 pm.
Address: 3 Consuelo Plaza, Oakdale, New York, USA. Phone: 631-589–2694
6. Claws Seafood Market
If you are looking for a restaurant to serve you some of the freshest natural seafood, Claws Seafood Market is perfect for that. But, of course, you can always count on the place with a view overlooking the water and New England-styled seafood market.
It has the best lobsters, market smoked and grilled fish, raw bar and some fantastic burgers.
While enjoying your meal in this stunning environment, there is a live band by the corner to set the tone for you.
Although you may have to wait a bit before you can be served, the friendly staff is there to give you a warm welcome. Besides, giving you the freshest meal to delight your appetite takes a little time.
To down your meal with something cold, Claws Seafood Market ensures to give you the best wine and beer.
Claws Seafood Market is open daily, except on Tuesday, from 12 – 7 pm.
Address: 20 Main St., Sayville, New York 11796, USA. Phone: 631-256–5900
7. Cornucopia
Family-owned and operated Cornucopia Natural Foods is a health food store established in 1976. It offers the best of organic, non-GMO foods that taste great for you.
The menu ranges from salad to burgers, vitamins and supplements, juice to smoothies, and everything healthy and natural.
Due to their choice of service, the place has become a unique place where people from all walks of life come to enjoy the taste of nature. While they aim to change the world, their presence in Sayville greatly impacts locals and visitors alike.
If you are a healthy food lover, it is time to give Cornucopia a chance to treat your taste bud.
Cornucopia is open from 9 am – 7 pm on Monday to Sunday. This is one of the best Sayville restaurants to consider for your food tour.
Address: 35 N. Main Str., Sayville, New York 11782, USA. Phone: 631 589 9579’
8. SweetFrog Frozen Yogurt
Perfect for all frosty lovers, SweetFrog is a place where you can create your imagination.
It offers a blend of delicious soft-serve frosty yogurt, and top it off with your favorite toppings.
It is simple – you select your flavor, add your topping and make your delicious yogurt precisely as you desire. Besides, every ingredient is prepared with your health in mind. So, you don’t have to worry about that because SweetFrog has already figured everything out.
Located in the heart of Sayville, you can always stop by in the afternoons and evenings for a bite of your favorite iced dessert and everything in between.
SweetFrog is open on Sunday to Thursday, from 12:00 pm to 9:30 pm, and Friday to Saturday, from 12:30 pm to 10:30 pm.
Address: Store #35153. 5640-35 Sunrise Highway. Sayville, New York 11782, USA. Phone: (631) 256-5933.
9. Blackbirds’ Grille
Located between Sayville and Bayport along Montauk highway, Blackbirds’ Grille is fast becoming one of the celebrated restaurants in Sayville, NY.
It is notable for its diverse and delicious menu, with television to entertain your presence. Their list of items includes seafood, pasta, and steaks. You can also select a range of desserts if you want something lighter.
The hamburger dish is extraordinarily delicious. Other dishes like jambalaya, baby back ribs, shrimp po’boy, and Cajun promise amazing tastes to everyone’s amusement.
With a homely staff trained to give you the best experience, you will not regret stepping into this super Sayville restaurant. You can equally come along with your family for a singular night out.
Blackbirds’ Grille is open on Monday to Friday, from 11:30 am – 10 pm, Saturday from 11:30 am – 10:30 pm and Sunday from 11 am – 10 pm.
Address: 553 Old Montauk Hwy, Sayville, NY 11782. Phone: +1 631-567-0900
10. Bluestone Tavern
In the heart of Sayville lies a local tavern that caters to the needs of locals and tourists. It is a superb place that specializes in flatbread, burgers, appetizers and pizzas.
The Bluestone Tavern is an excellent place to sit back and be taken care of over food and wine with family and friends. It provides a place to share casual meals and drinks with those who mean much to you.
Initially a chic dining room, the place has been transformed to a more casual pub dining place.
In creating a diverse and delicious menu, Blue Tavern ensures you find a perfect drink to blend with your meal choice. They offer a collection of curated drinks from 14 different beer recipes that can go well with your burger.
Bluestone Tavern is open daily from 11 am – 10 pm.
Address: 21 Montauk Hwy, West Sayville, New York 11796, USA. Phone: +1 631-567-0900
11. Parlor House Grill
One of the best restaurants in Sayville, NY, is Parlor House, this is another fantastic place in Sayville you can sneak in for your tasty bites. The site is kid-friendly, allowing parents to give their children amazing treats on weekends or holidays.
During summer, you can choose to eat your food outdoors on the patios, specifically made for the season.
Parlor House Grill is the best if you want a night that will not cost you much yet offers a delicious meal. It is also good for casual dinners and provides a takeout option.
Parlor House Grill is open on Monday to Friday, from 3 – 7 pm, Saturday, from 9 am – 12 pm and Sunday from 12 – 9 pm.
Address: 298 West Main Street, Sayville, NY, United States. Phone: 631-438-0733
12. La Tavola
Set in the stunning Sayville Village, La Tavola provides the locals with a special and tranquil dining experience. Its focus includes Italian foods and wine that give your taste bud a different experience.
The team and chef of the restaurant will treat you to a perfect meal. Each employs their current and creative skill to provide a traditional family recipe.
To set the mood right, a live acoustic plays in the background, with soft, sweet tones.
La Tavola is open on Monday – Friday, from 11:30 am – 9:30 pm, Saturday from 11:00 am – 10:00 pm and Sunday 11:00 am – 9:30 pm
Address: 183 W Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, United States. Phone: +1 631-750-6900
13. Council Oak Steak and Seafood Grill
Established as a small snack shop, the Oak Steak and Seafood Grill has become a connoisseur riverfront place. It offers any special meal that suits each occasion.
Right on Long Island, The Oar is loyal to its customers.
The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the walls are adorned to give you a pleasant environment, making this one of the best places to eat.
Among the meals at The Oar include fine steak and seafood for your lunch and dinner. If you are fascinated by water, you can choose the outdoor service where you will be welcomed with a stunning view.
Whatever you choose to eat, The Oar is there to give you an unforgettable experience.
Council Oak Steak and Seafood is open on Monday to Thursday, from 6 – 10:30 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 5 – 11:30 pm and Sunday from 5 – 10 pm.
Address: 264 West Ave., Patchogue, New York 11772-3543, USA. Phone: +1 631-654-8266
14. Sal’s Pizzeria and Catering
Sal’s Pizzeria is one of the oldest restaurants Sayville can boast of. It is a family-owned and operated restaurant which has passed through generations.
Acknowledged as one of New York’s finest pizza places, they offer you an unforgettable experience that would keep bringing you back.
At Sal’s Pizzeria, strict norms are followed to give customers quality service and presentation. Only the best of ingredients are used to ensure every meal is unique.
Foods are served on silverware and china plates, with the staff ready to serve you at your order.
Sal’s Pizzeria is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 10 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 11 pm and Sunday, from 12 – 10 pm.
Address: 183 North Main Street, Sayville, New York. Phone: (631) 567-1269
15. The Crab Shacks
Opened in 2000, Nancy’s Crab Shack is established with modern décor to give the outlook of modernity. It sits right on the waterside in Patchogue, NY.
Thus, it is famous for its specialization in seafood like clams, crabs, lobsters, shrimps, and oysters.
This casual restaurant has a patio close to the water for an excellent outdoor experience. In addition, there is a place for boat owners to dock their boats and come in for an amazing experience after a long day.
Stepping in there at night offers an out-of-the-world experience as live music is played to entertain visitors. There are also two bars at the place, all to ensure customers did not leave without receiving super service.
The Crabs Shack is open on Monday – Thursday, from 11 am – 10 pm, Friday – Saturday 11 am – 10:30 pm, and Sunday 11 am – 10 pm.
Address: 18 Maiden Lane, Patchogue, New York, USA. Phone: 631 447 6833
Plan a Trip to Sayville
Sayville is one of the oldest cities in New York. Due to its position near the Atlantic Ocean, it offers amazing opportunities for tourists to grace the city and have fun.
To help food lovers enjoy their stay in Sayville, some creative-minded individuals decided to create beautiful scenes on the streets and along the coasts with the finest restaurants. So, stepping into this city, some attractive views are centered on restaurants.
You may hardly resist the enticing views and tantalizing aromas oozing out of these Sayville restaurants. But it will first remind you of home.
Suppose you are a local or visitor in Sayville and would want to have a different experience for your taste bud, the above restaurants are perfect.